The great debate about the downfall of printed books and the role that ebooks play in that downfall still rages on. I’ll start this post with a quote highlighted in a book I’m currently reading, The Case for Books: Past, Present, and Future .
“…I have lately kept praising the age in which we live, because of the great, indeed divine gift of the new kind of writing (delivery system). …It was for this reason that I was led to hope that within a short time we should have such a large quantity of books that there wouldn’t be a single work which could not be procured because of a lack of means or scarcity…”
Care to guess what this quote refers to? Is it the Kindle, or even Google? Sorry, not even close. It’s from a letter written less than twenty years after Gutenberg’s Codex machine and references the hopes and fears related to impending change.
One more quote from this same book, and I think it’s important:
“…One medium does not displace another…newspapers did not wipe out the printed books, the radio did not displace the newspaper, television did not destroy the radio and the Internet did not make viewers abandon their TV sets.”
In short, there is plenty of room for ebooks and the printed word. Can electrons live side by side with cellulose fiber? If I were pressed to make a prediction I’d say, “Absolutely. At least for the foreseeable future.”
The machinery of time turns slowly, my friends. Bibliophiles will not be trashing their book collections anytime soon. Every day in the library, I see today’s youth coming in and checking out YA books by the dozen. There seems to be some kind of balance between Warriors and the World of Warcraft.
As well, I consider myself balanced in this regard. Oh, boy do I love my Kindle. I love reading from it, I love the portability and the features. I love the free content available and paying nine bucks for a bestseller hurts me feelings nary one bit. With that said you can have my books when you pry them from my cold, dead hands. I love my bookcase. I love adding books to it whenever I can. I don’t think I’m special or unusual in this regard. My sister told me recently, “I love my Kindle, but I’ll always be a page turner.” Couldn’t have said it better myself.
I don’t believe that e-books will ever completely displace the printed word. There is room enough for both.
Where do you weigh in on the Great Debate?














