At the numerous cocktail parties I attend (hehe, yeah, right) I’m oft asked what I do for a living. And though it still sounds a little funny passing my lips, my response is, “I’m a writer.” Invariably the next question is, “What do you write?” At which point I blather on about freelancing, blogs, web content, yadda-yadda-yadda. Polite smiles all around, maybe a, “That’s nice.” Soon followed by semi-hasty departures sung to the tune of, “I’m going to go find someone interesting to talk to.”
Consider for a moment what the conversation would be like if my initial response had been, “I’m an author.” Wow. That’s got a different ring to it. It conjures up visions of secluded cabins, late night furious writing sessions, tweed sportcoats with supple leather elbow patches and straight stemmed pipes.
Dictionary.com sez:
Writer:
- a person engaged in writing books, articles, stories, etc., esp. as an occupation or profession
- a clerk, scribe, or the like
- a person who commits his or her thoughts, ideas, etc., to writing
Author:
- a person who writes a novel, poem, essay, etc.; the composer of a literary work, as distinguished from a compiler, translator, editor, or copyist
- the maker of anything; creator; originator
- the literary production or productions of a writer
The difference between the two is subtle, but it’s there.
In my mind, you are an author when you complete a project of non-fiction or fiction, package it and put it out for the world to see. Technically, I guess using that philosophy you could say that when you complete a blog post you could call your self an author. But is that genuine and accurate? I don’t really think it is. So let me shape the definition a bit more: You are an author when you complete a book. There, how’s that? Does that sit a little better? Or does it kinda make you mad?
The point is that in the eyes of the general populous, a writer is different from an author and the two are on completely different levels. I think that to some extent, it’s picking nits, but remember that (and I hate this, even though it’s true) reality is not what matters – it’s people’s perception of reality that is the ultimate criteria.
So if you write web content, and have two or three half finished novels in the works and you’ve entered a short story into a contest, would you feel comfortable calling yourself an author? Put yourself into the cocktail party scenario. Imagine giving the, “I’m an author” response. How does that feel? Would you handle any follow up questions any differently than you would if you said you were a writer?
I think this is a very interesting topic to consider. I’m willing to bet that opinions on this are impassioned and varied.
Let the debate begin!
Oh man! I could stack those polite smiles to the ceiling. I can’t believe how often people break eye contact at the word blog. No doubt, George, it is perception that matters. I love the word writer and will continue to use it, but I think I may just bandy author about as well. Thanks.
Writer Dad´s last blog post..The Collective Inkwell Creative Fiction Contest – Win a pimped out Thesis Theme!
This is an interesting conundrum that is close to my heart. I am very comfortable with saying I’m a writer, as I keep a roof over my family by writing. I turn words into pennies and there is no denying that.
I have written a book – it’s all finished and everything. But the issue I would have in the cocktail party scenario above is that if I said I was an author, I feel there is an implicit assumption that one has been published. So in that situation, I think they would react more positively, ask what I wrote… and then there’s the rub – would I admit at that point that it is still unpublished?
So I think I will stick to ‘writer’ till I get that contract (or do it myself). It may all be in my mind, but there it is all the same!
Emma Newman´s last blog post..Ten writing lessons learned – a reminder to my future self
Very good thought, George; don’t know how many times I’ve used the word “writer”, but the listener looses interest when I mention it’s, y’know, that um, blog thingie… (sound of stampede for the door)
Anyhoo, now that I’m actually gonna match up with that definition of the word “author” – hey, I’m going to try it out and see what happens. Maybe I’ll even use the golden descriptive “published” in front of it, just for spice, don’cha think?
Robert Hruzek´s last blog post..Location, Location, Location
Hi there, Writer Dad!
Really nice to have you here. I’ll be interested in hearing how the responses vary when you toss “author” out there now and then!
Headed over to enter the contest, Sir. Looks like a lot of fun!
Cheers
George
Emma,
That is exactly what I’m talking about. It’s interesting that the definitions are so close, yet as writers we are loathe to use the “A” word unless we have a tangible thing in our hands (that hopefully has sold 10 million copies)
Thanks for stopping by!
Hey Robert!
You go, big fella. Let me know how many autographs you get!
Oh, also here is some free advice: If you sign anyone’s copy of your ebook, don’t use a permanent sharpie. I’m still trying to scrub mine off the monitor…
George
Aw, c’mon, George – any idiot knows you’re supposed to use a rubber stamp! No wait -
Robert Hruzek´s last blog post..Location, Location, Location
You think they walk away fast when you tell them you blog, try this. When somebody asks what you do, just reply with “on what day?”…they’ll usually get the idea that you’re a bit different and move on to another topic.
In all seriousness though, this is soemthing I’ve thought about. I don’t consider myself a writer, yet I write everyday. And I’m certainly no author, by any stretch of the word. So I don’t know where the heck I fit in all this.
Matt
Matt | Small Biz Bee´s last blog post..One Quick Tip to Get More Sales
Great thought provoking article.
I tend to use the term writer most of the time. However, being a published author of 6 books, numerous stories, poems and articles, plays that have been performed and several thousand blog posts, I feel I’ve been short changing myself all these years.
When actually in the act of writing – I am a writer. When I’m published – be that in a magazine, book form, e-zine or blog post – I am definitely an Author.
Time to raise the stakes, methinks.
And hopefully get some respect. After all, I’ve worked hard for it.
Trevor Hampel´s last blog post..How sweet it is
Subtle in the dictionary, but big and stompy in the real world, as you have noticed.
I agree that “author” = “published”. Unfortunately, with the proliferation of POD publishing, pretty much anyone these days can call themselves and author…merited or not.
Merrilee Faber´s last blog post..Not back in the saddle, but standing beside it, glaring.
I agree, the definition of the word (author) is dictated by actual usage among actual people. A dictionary is a servant to word usage, isn’t it?
In that case, to me, an author has written a book. Period.
A writer, even if he or she makes millions of dollars a year is not an author until a book is published.
Matt,
Where you fit in, my friend is right at the top of the heap. Your writing style is active and engaging. In addition to being informative, your posts are a joy to read. Excellent sense of humor combined with a conversational style.
Yes Matt, you ARE a writer.
George
Trevor,
Thanks for coming by and contributing. I’m glad to see you here.
I think you nailed it. The amount of work you obviously put into the craft warrants the title, to be sure.
I’m heading over to your site to have a look around.
Cheers
George
Ahhh, Merrilee,
So now a can of worms is open. Excellent point.
Well, Tumblemoose readers, how does POD affect your definition?
Good job.
George
Bamboo,
I think that most folks are in your camp, Ryan.
Well put.
George
Ah, words!
We wear words like badges, don’t we. We love to pigeonhole people, including ourselves. It helps us make sense of the nonsensical.
He’s a this. She’s a that. That group is Gen-this. This group is anti-that.
I have to laugh. How many times have I seen a pimply-faced teenager ( no offence, teens) at the local pizza emporium proudly wearing the badge “Manager.”
He’s no more a “manager” than the next guy. He slathers on generic ingredients (maybe even a booger or two, if he’s on YouTube) and probably takes out the trash, all for close to minimum wage. But he’s a “manager.”
Yes, I’m a writer AND a published author.
But you can call me Wayne or Mister Long, thank you. I put my pants on one leg at a time, just like the rest of you.
The only thing that makes each of us “writers” unique is how we use our infinitely-large, God-given talents. Some folks have just scratched the surface of their real potential, probably because they are too consumed with trying to act the part at cocktail parties. Trying to impress. Trying to … what? … fit into that proverbial pidgeonhole.
I’d much rather not fit into ANYBODY’S existing mold. I choose to break the mold. I choose to make my OWN art.
Excuse me. I have to post this comment to George Angus. He’s a “Tumblemoose,” you know.
Or worse yet, is he an “Alaskan?”
A man?
How about “friend.”
Wayne C. Long
Writer/Editor/Internet Publisher
http://www.LongShortStories.com
This is such a touchy topic, George. You know, what amazes me is that every time I tell someone I’m a writer, they ask: Really? What books have you written? I’m thinking what? Oh well. I don’t know. I get tired of explaining it, don’t you? I mean, what does it matter? Most of these people who are giving those looks about us being writers are flipping burgers or are stuck in some stressful, horrific job that keeps them awake at night. I don’t grill them about that. Why should they make a big deal about articles, blogs, and essays? Ya know?
Oh, I could go on and on!
Now, about that cabin. Oh, George, you have me fantasizing. How will I ever get my work done now??!! LOL Seriously, though, I’ve always wanted a cozy cabin nestled in thick woods where I could write with the nearby fireplace crackling and throwing off warmth and the vibe of home.
Okay, I’ll let someone else have a little white space to say something now.
*giggles*
Michele
Michele´s last blog post..Contest Giveaway: 3 DVD Set — Raw for Thirty and Raw for Life
I’m a good old fashioned hack!
I think I’ll agree with those that say author carries the connotation of having been published and having some sort of legitimate credentials to back them up.
When I tell people I write a blog, they assume it’s about my kids and I’m writing it for Grandma and the aunties.
Tracy´s last blog post..A List of 10 Randoms and a Blog Reader Appreciation Day Prize
Fantastic reading, as we can always expect from you. Good job George!
Johnny´s last blog post..Efficient Blogging
Hmm, I think that there is another possible line that could divide a an author from just a writer. I think that an author could more be defined as someone who writes for the love of writing and the love of language. Published or not makes no difference to me.
I don’t think that author is different from writer, rather it is a subcategory of writer.
LoneWolf´s last blog post..Two Feet at a Time — Wood Master Part II
Michele,
That does make for some uncomfortable convos for certain.
I dream all the time of a private writing paradise…
George
Tracy,
Um, I think it’s hacktress. And you are one heck of one.
Much luvs – George
Johnny AKA 100K:
Thanks so much. Nice to see you here, stumble buddy.
I appreciate the kind words – makes me feel great, it does.
Cheers
George
Wolfie,
That’s an interesting distinction. The line may be fine.
Thanks for contributing to what has become a very interesting discussion.
George
I’ve always wanted to be a writer….author doesn’t have the same ring of creativity or artistic sense to me. I see authors as dry, literary, and hard to slog through! I see writers as quirky, interesting, and better paid
When I write articles for magazines, I always refer to my sources as “Dr Z, author of X.” Not writer. Writer seems more like a verb (even though it’s a noun). Writer seems more action-oriented…author seems more passive.
Great post, George! Thanks for letting me ramble my thoughts….
Laurie
Laurie PK´s last blog post..How to Make Your Articles, Pitches, and Writing Memorable
I had a discussion like this with the high school career day organizer when she was trying to figure out what table I should sit at… She doesn’t call me any more.
I think Author does indicate accomplishment to a certain extent. Your claim to being an author comes after the work is completed and ready to view.
Fred H Schlegel´s last blog post..Physics and Ideation: Ways To Unleash Creativity
Wayne:
That is a great perspective. Thanks for injecting a dose of realism and pragmatism into the conversation.
I apologize for the delayed response to your comment, Apparently the spam Gods had a case of indigestion.
It is nice to see you here (as always).
Oh, and I put my kilt on two legs at a time.
Signed,
Tumblemoose, an Alaskan, a man, a friend, George
Hi Laurie,
You just head on over here and ramble all you like – any time you like. Nice to have you here.
Now see? Yours is an interesting perspective. Yes, the author image does conjure up a certain vision.
I like the concept of writer = active. I hadn’t thought of it that way before but I think it rings true.
Cheers
George
Hi Fred.
Thanks for coming by and contributing.
Nice story about the high school career day. Where did you end up?
George
‘creative consultant’
Try to explain that career path to college bound high schoolers.
Fred H Schlegel´s last blog post..Physics and Ideation: Ways To Unleash Creativity
Great post, George.
I remember the first time I said, “I’m a writer” to someone who asked what I did for a living. I can still remember the chills and how great it sounded coming from my mouth because I felt so proud to say it aloud. I had told people for years that I was a writer trapped in a corporate body and to finally just say “Writer” was *so* sweet.
I had no idea of the differences between writer and author in the dictionary sense. I’m with Laurie PK…
Writer definitely sounds more adventurous!
Cheers,
Dana
Dana – The Writer’s Blog´s last blog post..Favourite Writer Blogs – GetPaidToWriteOnline
Hi Dana,
Nice to have you come by!
There is something liberating about saying, “I’m a writer.” It makes me proud to do so, really.
Yeah, I think Ms. Laurie may have hit the ol’ nail on the head.
Cheers!
George
When I say, “Writer” — people automatically assume print publications. Well, if I limit my career to that … it might as well be out of work writer. I think those dreaming of becoming a writer focus too much on book and print publications. If they’d expand their thinking, they’ll have better success and sooner.
Though I have published and contributed to several books, I never use “author.” I think “writer” sounds broader, which is what I am.
Meryl Evans´s last blog post..9 Ways to Brand YOU
Meryl,
That is key. There are so many venues and opportunities and when one limits themselves… They end up limited!
George
Interesting definitional discussion. I agree that ‘author’ sounds like something completed and publicly shared, and ‘writer’ like something in process, perhaps even unfinished. No one says “I’m the writer of xyz.” S/he says, “I’m the author of…” and so does his/her bio. Subtle but definitely a distinction.
Mary´s last blog post..Speculating on Publishing’s Future
Hi Mary,
It’s very nice to see you here, thanks for coming by and contributing.
I agree that there is a distinction – subtle but there.
I’m heading over to look at your web site right now.
George
Yikes! Talked to a friend recently who has been cooking up a book for a few years and plans to start working on it. He also wants to start doing article writing. I don’t want to rain on my friend’s parade — he could very well make it.
But this is the kind of thing you hear that sounds like what most people think and is unrealistic.
Hi Meryl,
I think that yes, a little reality check is probably in order for your friend. Nothing discouraging, so much as turning on a few lights.
George
Hi George!
I think it’s interesting that while I hesitate to tell people I’m a writer (even tho’ I’ve finished 3 novels, am published and placed on 2 short story sites and have TONS more coming!!), my husband brags about it.
I think author = published and I hope I will be able to call myself that soon.
I’m looking forward to following you more – this looks like a fun group!
Hi Genevieve,
It’s nice to see you here – glad you stopped by!
It’s nice to have a support system that recognizes that you ARE a writer and is ready to sing your praises.
I look forward to having you around!
Cheers
George
I’ve published a poetry book and I write poetry, short stories and articles that are published online. I usually call myself a writer. I recently took off the word freelance. I would like the title of Author, but I am told that in the writing world a poetry book just doesn’t make the list of publications that qualify for the title of Author.