Are you a closet writer?


A writer’s world is generally a solitary one.  Even with partnerships and co-authoring, group projects and such, when it comes right down to it writing is a solitary sport.  For some folks it’s even more solitary because they write, and their writing is their own little secret.

I recently started a Writer’s Forum with Tracy O’Connor at her  I Hate My Message Board site.  I think that one of the most interesting things I discovered were the amount of folks who considered themselves “closet writers”.  While I think there is not a true and complete definition in place for this term, I would consider someone a closet writer if they put words to paper and no one other than them ever sees it.

The other thing that became clear is that some folks just have no intention of writing for others to read.  In terms of closet writers, I think that these personal writers are in the minority.  I think that most closet writers are in the closet because they they think that:

  • Their writing isn’t good enough for anyone to see
  • No one would read it anyway
  • They may fail at writing (fear of criticism)
  • They may succeed at writing

There may be any number of reasons a particular writer stays hidden in the shadows, but I’d bet these are probably the most common.  And just let me say that if someone is really ok with being in the shadows, then far be it for me to drag them kicking and screaming into the cold, harsh light.  For those others that need a little nudge and encouragement to take those first baby steps, this post’s for you.

First, your writing is good enough.  It really is.  No matter if your grammar is imperfect or if you are the queen of dangling participles.  If you really want to call yourself a writer and put your stuff out there you must kill your perfectionist.  Stomp the ever-lovin’ life out of that sod and kick him to the curb.  At some point you may come back and pull him from the gutter, but if your perfectionist is keeping you from moving forward, he needs to go away – at least for a while.

People will read what you write, and there are literally dozens of venues from which to choose.  You could post at forums, start a blog, join a writer’s group.  There are ways to get your writing read.  Explore the options that are the most comfortable for you.

What is your definition of failure?  Is it reasonable? If you think failure is not having your first novel end up on the NYT Best seller list then you need to re-evaluate your meaning of failure.  Set reasonable expectations for what you want to accomplish and your chances of failure go way down.  Don’t know where to start? Consider the intimate setting of having someone you trust have a look at your writing.  It’s very important that you trust and respect this person.  Handing over that first manuscript to someone can be a lump in your throat experience.

As strange as it seems, some folks are scared to death of being successful.  Oh, they may not realize or verbalize it, but their interior word track tells them that they are not worthy of success and therefore should not even try to move forward with this process.  This could keep someone in the closet for a very long time.  Try to keep in mind that the brass ring is there for the taking, and that no one deserves this more than you.  There is a great post today over at The Adventurous Writer with 13 outstanding tips on improving your confidence.  It is worth it to head on over and check it out.

There is nothing wrong with being a closet writer if that is what you truly want.  If you are a closet writer because of these other barriers, then go ahead and take your first few steps and come on in – The water’s fine!

Along the same lines...

19 Responses to Are you a closet writer?
  1. Thom Allen
    January 5, 2009 | 7:41 am

    Great and ironic post. While I don’t consider myself to be a closet writer, people are often surprised when I tell them I write.

    While I admit I’ve had some of the closet writer fears, for me its been my use of grammar. In my head I fear what I put on paper will sound ridicules because of the way I structure sentences, word choice, and punctuation.

    I occasionally read the review of a story or book, and someone says it was full of typos and missing punctuation. I read it, and I can’t see one typo. But I’m sure it has to be the its/it’s, or your/you’re kind of typo.

    I appreciate all of the encouragement I get from people like yourself. I don’t know everything, and I’m no threat to anyone yet (I say with a smile). Encouragement is crucial, along with criticism. I can take both, in ample amounts.

    Thanks again for the great post.

    Thom Allen´s last blog post..Reading On Grammar

  2. Justine
    January 5, 2009 | 7:48 am

    Lovely, inspiring post. It’s taken me nigh on 30 years to be able to say ‘I’m a writer’ when someone asks me what I do. I felt, as you say, scared of failure, scared of bad opinion, scared of everything. Writing for others to read is always a bit like baring one’s soul: deeply frightening. For me, the thing that got me writing publicly was starting an excellent writing course, where I suddenly didn’t feel so alone: everyone else was as scared as me, I met some great people, read some fabulous writing and, amazingly, received acclaim for what I wrote. If nothing else, such courses allow you to mix with & be inspired by like-minded folk & you never know, it could be the start of something really special & successful.

    Justine´s last blog post..Novel editing: the number 1 cause of procrastination. Fact.

  3. george
    January 5, 2009 | 7:49 am

    Hey Thom,
    Thanks for dropping by and leaving such a great comment. You know, when I see typos in a published book, I don’t blame the writer as much as I do the editor. I think they should be the ones who catch those kinds of things. A stray typo or two is ok, but I’ve read books before where I wonder how it ever made it to the press.

    I hope you come back to visit.

    Cheers

    George

  4. george
    January 5, 2009 | 7:52 am

    Hi Justine (with an “e”) ;-)

    Your point of a writing course is excellent! Getting folks on the same level, especially if the prof has made it a safe classroom is an excellent way to bring someone out of their writing shell.

    So glad you stopped by, and I gotta say I’m enjoying the heck out of your Tweets!

    George

  5. Cash2Blog
    January 5, 2009 | 7:52 am

    This post is great for inspiring closet writers and also giving them motivation to become successful or at least more confident in their writings. I was never a writer before creating my blog, and had a lot of these feelings at first.

    Cash2Blog´s last blog post..5 Twitter Tools Worth Taking A Look At

  6. george
    January 5, 2009 | 8:06 am

    Hey Cash.

    Always good to see you here, you know.

    I think blogging is a great first step. Easy as pie, doesn’t cost a thing and gives a strong sense of accomplishment.

    Cheers!

    George

  7. Ulla Hennig
    January 5, 2009 | 9:06 am

    Thanks, George, for your encouraging post! I am “only” blogging, but the fears you describe I know very well. My main fear is that my writing is not good enough, and when I hit “publish” and set my post free I always have that question in mind “will it be good enough?”. But nevertheless, I keep on publishing my posts.

    Ulla Hennig´s last blog post..Happy New Year!

  8. george
    January 5, 2009 | 9:33 am

    Hi Ulla,

    I feel your pain with that. There’s always a little bit of, “Oh my God, what have I done?” when I hit “Publish”

    Thanks for coming by and commenting

  9. Ulla Hennig
    January 5, 2009 | 9:35 am

    Hi George,

    I can’t see any reason for you feeling that way – I deeply enjoy your posts!

    Ulla Hennig´s last blog post..Happy New Year!

  10. george
    January 5, 2009 | 9:39 am

    Ulla,

    Thanks for that. Really. I think it’s just part of being a writer – I think we are our own toughest critics.

    George

  11. Dee Langdon - BloggerNewbie
    January 5, 2009 | 3:18 pm

    I’m not a closet writer but I have all of the above fears and sometimes they can be paralyzing. I have about 30 posts started and practically finished but I need to wait – something is missing or not right! Fear really freezes you into procrastination.

    Okay, no one has asked but what’s up with the picture?

    Dee Langdon – BloggerNewbie´s last blog post..Courage is

  12. george
    January 5, 2009 | 4:15 pm

    I’m tellin ya, Dee. Pull that little SOB of a perfectionist into the closest alley and beat the snot out of her. Let me know, and I’ll even help.

    Things do not have to be perfect – they do, however need to be real.

    The pic? Oh, that old thing – ran across it the other day and scanned it in. From my old LAFD days

    George

  13. Tracy
    January 5, 2009 | 5:45 pm

    “What is your definition of failure? Is it reasonable?”

    That hits home for me and is probably my biggest weakness in everything. I’ve got the classic perfectionist personality coupled with having easy success early in life. As I got older and things became less easy, I became very frustrated especially as I’d never formed good work habits. It is hard for me to shake the idea that if I’m not going to be the best at something there isn’t a point in trying.

    I’m working hard at overcoming this, for myself and because I’ve got five young people watching me and I don’t want them to form the same attitude.

    And by golly, I will be the best overcomer ever! I will!

    Tracy´s last blog post..Why I Love My Message Board

  14. george
    January 5, 2009 | 5:59 pm

    Tracy,

    OK then. You and Dee get together, come on over and bring your perfectionists with you and we’ll have ourselves a little stomp party.

    It’s ok to have high standards, as long as it doesn’t stifle you from moving forward with your goals and aspirations.

  15. Laurie PK
    January 6, 2009 | 6:34 am

    I’m the opposite of a closet writer — I tend to send my article pitches and book proposals out far too early! I need to learn to massage my ideas more.

    One of my dear friends has been writing in the closet for almost 25 years now. He’s written at least 3 novels, but never sends them to publishers or editors. He thinks he’s afraid of success…I tease him that he’s lazy (and he agrees). But, I always think he’ll be one of those writers who suddenly bursts out of the closet and becomes famous at 65 or 70 years old……

    Being a closet writer gives you lots of practice!

    Laurie PK´s last blog post..13 Tips on Improving Your Confidence as a Writer

  16. george
    January 6, 2009 | 8:04 am

    Hi Laurie,

    I’d like to see that happen for your friend, maybe sooner!

    Closet writing can give you lots of practice, and after all the important thing is that you are doing the writing!

    Chhers

    George

  17. Closet
    January 22, 2009 | 9:56 pm

    Hi,

    Nice post. Thanks to George for posting this entry and for sharing.

    Nancy.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks
  1. There Is Plenty Of Room For Your Story : Galactic Writer
  2. The Accidental Profiteer | i Profit On Purpose
Leave a Reply


Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

CommentLuv Enabled
Trackback URL http://tumblemoose.com/are-you-a-closet-writer/trackback/